Does Echinacea Actually Help With Cold Symptoms?
Reading time: 6 minutes
|
Key Takeaways
- Echinacea is a well-known herbal remedy, but studies show it may not work better than a fake pill (placebo) for treating cold symptoms.
- Traditional cold medicines, like decongestants and pain relievers, have been used for a long time and are made to help with specific symptoms.
- Choosing between supplements and medicine depends on what works best for your body. A doctor or pharmacist can help you make the right choice.
Most people catch a cold once or twice a year. A cold can make your nose run, your throat hurt, and your body feel tired. You might cough or have a mild fever.
To feel better, some people take regular cold medicine, like decongestants or pain relievers. Others try natural remedies, such as teas, honey, or herbs.
One popular natural option is Echinacea. It’s a plant that comes in different forms—like tea, pills, or drops. People take it hoping it will help them get better faster.
Many believe that Echinacea helps the body fight off colds, but not all scientists agree. A recent study compared Echinacea to a sugar pill (called a placebo). The results showed that there was not much difference between the two.
This brings up a common question:
Should people use Echinacea, or stick with regular cold medicine?
What Is Echinacea?
Echinacea is a plant that grows in parts of North America. It has purple petals and a spiky, cone-shaped center, which is why some people call it the coneflower.
There are different types of Echinacea, but only a few are used to make herbal remedies. These products are usually found as teas, pills, or liquid drops.
People have used Echinacea for many years as a natural way to help with colds. Some take it when they start feeling sick. Others use it to try to stop a cold from happening.
Many believe that Echinacea can support the immune system, which helps the body fight off germs. But scientists are still studying how well it actually works. Some research says it might help a little. Other studies say there’s no strong effect.
Some people use Echinacea along with other supplement medications when they want a natural choice instead of regular cold medicine. These products are easy to find and are sold in stores and online.
The Study – Does Echinacea Work?
A group of researchers wanted to find out if Echinacea really helps people feel better when they have a cold. They ran a study in Dane County, Wisconsin, to test this idea.
In the study, 719 people who had colds were split into two groups. One group took Echinacea. The other group took a placebo, which is a fake pill that doesn’t contain any real medicine.
The researchers looked at how long the colds lasted and how strong the symptoms were in both groups.
At the end of the study, the people who took Echinacea did not feel much different from those who took the placebo. Both groups felt a little better over time, but the Echinacea pill did not work better than the fake one.
This study shows that Echinacea may not help more than a placebo. It also brings up more questions about whether Echinacea is a good choice for treating cold symptoms.
What Are the Limits of the Study?
The study on Echinacea and the common cold gave some useful information. However, there were also a few limits that could affect how the results apply to other people.
First, the study was done in just one place — Dane County, Wisconsin. People in other areas may have different lifestyles, weather, or healthcare systems. Because of this, the results might not be the same everywhere.
Second, most of the 719 people in the study were white — about 88%. People from other racial or ethnic backgrounds might react differently to Echinacea. This means the results may not apply to everyone.
Third, the researchers tested only one kind of Echinacea, in just one form. But there are many types of Echinacea sold in stores, and they come in different doses and mixtures. Other versions might work differently.
Because of these limits, the researchers believe that more studies are needed. Testing more people in different places could help show whether Echinacea works better for some groups than others.
Comparing Cold Remedies
The common cold causes symptoms that many people know. These include a stuffy nose, sore throat, coughing, sneezing, and sometimes a mild fever. While a cold usually goes away in a few days, people often look for ways to feel more comfortable while they recover.
There are two main ways people treat cold symptoms:
traditional medicine and herbal remedies.
Traditional cold medicine, like Sudafed, is sold in pharmacies. It is made to treat specific symptoms, such as blocked sinuses or a runny nose. These products often work quickly and are used by people who want fast relief.
Herbal remedies, like Echinacea, are made from plants. Some people choose these because they prefer natural options. Many believe Echinacea may help the body fight off colds or shorten how long they last. But research has not shown strong proof that it works better than regular medicine.
People still disagree on which type of cold treatment is better. Some follow what has worked for them in the past. Others ask their doctor or pharmacist for advice.
So, What Should You Take for a Cold?
When you have a cold, it’s helpful to think about what your body needs. Most colds go away in a few days without any special treatment. Still, many people want something to feel better while they recover.
Some people choose traditional cold medicine to lower a fever, clear a stuffy nose, or stop a cough. These medicines are sold in pharmacies and are made to treat specific symptoms.
Others prefer natural remedies, like warm tea, honey, or supplements such as Echinacea. These are often picked by people who like plant-based or gentle options. Some say they feel better after using them, even though the science is still being studied.
Before trying something new, it’s a good idea to talk with a doctor or pharmacist. They can help you pick the treatment that fits your symptoms, age, and health. This can also help you avoid side effects or problems with other medications.
Conclusion
The study on Echinacea showed that it may not work better than a placebo. A placebo is a fake pill that doesn’t contain any medicine. People who took Echinacea felt about the same as those who took the fake pill. This means that Echinacea might not have a strong effect on cold symptoms.
On the other hand, traditional cold medicines like decongestants and pain relievers have been used for many years. These are made to treat specific symptoms, such as a stuffy nose or body aches, and often help people feel better while they recover.
Before changing how you treat a cold, it’s helpful to talk to a doctor or pharmacist. They can help you find a safe option that works well for your symptoms and health needs.
To explore both traditional cold treatments and natural remedies, visit Online Pharmacies Canada, where you can find a variety of cold medications and supplement products delivered to your door.
Information provided on this website is for general purposes only. It is not intended to take the place of advice from your practitioner